Visible to the public File preview

Advancing the science of cybersecurity with a virtual organization
Frankie King, Heather Lucas, and Robert Meushaw



he National Science Foundation (NSF)’s Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS) program is a research initiative to support the development of systems that combine physical, computing, and communications components at very large scale and high complexity. Cyber-physical systems are not the traditional desktop computers, embedded/real-time systems, and sensor nets with which we are familiar today. ey are characterized by cyber capabilities in all physical components, networking at multiple and extreme scales, high degrees of automation, dynamic recon guration and reorganization, and extreme requirements for dependability and reliability. Although cyber-physical systems are currently being planned and developed to support applications in numerous areas (e.g., the smart power grid, smart healthcare, and smart transportation), the scienti c understanding and engineering tools needed to realize such systems with high-con dence reliability and dependability are lacking.

to advance the theory, engineering, and operation of cyber-physical systems. A primary objective of the CPS VO is to overcome some of the major impediments to progress in complex systems science, such as the lack of integration and cross-fertilization of numerous traditionally isolated disciplines. e NSF intended the CPS VO to enable electronic community building and to provide a vehicle for sharing information among otherwise disparate researchers, students, educators, and industry practitioners within the growing cross-disciplinary eld of cyber-physical systems. Vanderbilt University was selected by NSF to develop and manage the CPS VO. It was built using DRUPAL, a widely used, free, and open-source content management system that provides the back end for at least two percent of all websites worldwide, including e system is exible and highly customizable, providing a rich set of capabilities for the CPS VO user community. e CPS VO was initially used to advertise the activities of the CPS program and to establish electronic forums for many of the common interest groups (e.g., medical, automotive, aviation, education, and architectures) within the national High Con dence So ware and Systems Coordinating Group. e High Con dence So ware and Systems Coordinating Group (HCSS CG) is part of the national Networking and Information Technology Research and Development (NITRD) Program. (For more information on NITRD, see

e CPS Virtual Organization (CPS VO), an o shoot of the CPS program, was envisioned as a tool to promote and support a broad spectrum of collaborative interactions among researchers to assist in solving complex, crosscutting problems requiring expertise from multiple domains. e CPS VO provides a web-based gathering place and clearinghouse for knowledge relevant to cyber-physical systems and


Establishing a virtual organization for cybersecurity science
At a high level, NSF’s CPS program and the federal cyber-physical systems research portfolio can be seen as a broad research initiative intended to develop the scienti c foundations for designing complex systems. Many of the activities associated with cyber-physical systems have focused on identifying the technical challenges associated with various types of complex systems. In late 2010, NITRD agencies, led by NSA and NSF, launched one such activity related to the science of dependable and secure cyber-physical systems. is e ort culminated in the Workshop on Foundations of Dependable and Secure Cyber-Physical Systems, held as part of CPS Week 2011 in Chicago, Illinois. (For more information, see e workshop focused on topics that addressed fundamental challenges of making cyber-physical systems secure, dependable, and trustworthy. Particular emphasis was placed on the control and veri cation challenges arising from the complex interdependencies among networked systems. Such systems are in widespread use today, controlling the operation of critical infrastructures such as power transmission, water distribution, transportation, healthcare, building automation, and process control. e combination of various factors—including the widespread use of commodity components, Internet connectivity, and the malicious intents of hackers and cybercriminals—have made these types of systems extremely vulnerable. Despite attempts to apply security-oriented design

guidelines and policies, much remains to be done to achieve a scienti cally grounded and principled design approach to security, trustworthiness, and dependability in these systems. e 2011 workshop was a rst formal attempt to foster collaboration among researchers from a variety of elds including control and systems theory, embedded systems, game theory, so ware veri cation and formal methods, and computer security. One important outcome of the workshop was the recognition that the science of cybersecurity was critical to the overall success of the CPS program and of the cyber-physical systems eld. is recognition aligned with the vision that had been previously put forward by the NITRD HCSS CG cochairs in a white paper to the O ce of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) titled “Winning the future with science and technology for 21st century smart systems.” Workshop recommendations went even further, recommending that a virtual organization dedicated to cybersecurity science be established within the CPS VO—the Science of Security Virtual Organization (SoS VO).

Growing interest in cybersecurity science
At the same time as the CPS program moved toward creating a distinct cybersecurity science group, a number of governmental initiatives in cybersecurity science began appearing from organizations across the broader cybersecurity community, including several outside of the US. Unfortunately, without the bene t of any centralized resource to help coordinate

The Next Wave | Vol. 19 No. 4 | 2012 | 21

Advancing the science of cybersecurity with a virtual organization

their e orts, these activities developed in isolation. As information about these e orts became more widely available, it became clear that the SoS VO could serve an even more valuable role if it provided a focal point for all things cybersecurity science related. Together, through NSA leadership and sponsorship, Vanderbilt’s design goal for the CPS VO was augmented to provide a portal with a rich set of collaboration and sharing capabilities, leveraging and extending NSF’s investment to support an enhanced data repository and content management system. is coordinated e ort served well the interest of both the CPS VO and SoS VO communities. While this approach was signi cantly more ambitious, it o ered better opportunities for advancing work in both cyber-physical systems and cybersecurity science much more quickly and e ciently. e integrated approach and the resulting extended capabilities will bene t other cyber-physical systems special interest groups as they begin building their online communities.

a focal point for information about ongoing activities related to cybersecurity science and as a repository for signi cant research results. e second phase of development would place emphasis on community development, information sharing, and interaction among researchers in the eld. e last, and most ambitious, set of capabilities envisioned for the SoS VO would help to establish and support true collaboration in advancing cybersecurity science. (See gure 1 for a screenshot of the SoS VO home page.)

SoS VO capability phases
Phase 1. Build a resource center.

Content is king, search is queen
From its inception, the CPS VO was intended to grow into an established research resource by o ering a storehouse of information with a robust search capability to mine it e ciently. Achieving this goal meant that the virtual organization needed to attract a large user population and provide services that were valuable, engaging, and easy to use. ese objectives were adopted as the guiding principles for all decisions made in augmenting support for the SoS VO. e target audience was expanded to include researchers, program managers, educators, funding agents, system designers, and students—almost anyone having an interest in cybersecurity science. Attracting such a broad group meant the SoS VO had to provide an extensive and useful assortment of information, accessible intuitively and e ciently—a very tall order. If the SoS VO is able to create an enduring engagement center for cybersecurity science, user-contributed content should generate value and further help to build a cybersecurity science community.

Creating a centralized information resource on cybersecurity science activity is the rst step planned for the SoS VO and is key to helping establish a community. An important goal of this phase involves identifying and collecting information about the disparate cybersecurity science work currently being performed. Providing descriptions and contact information for the organizations conducting and supporting cybersecurity science work is a priority, as well as advertising new program funding opportunities. For organizations currently producing reports related to cybersecurity science, the SoS VO intends to provide a centralized library for cataloging, analyzing, searching, and distributing information. A calendar of events related to cybersecurity science is a core capability of the SoS VO and will appear early with the ability to sync to users’ individual calendars.
Phase 2. Cultivate collaboration with virtual tools.

Evolving an SoS VO capability
A er a careful assessment of the needs identi ed for the SoS VO, a plan was developed to roll out new capabilities in three basic areas. e rst set of capabilities was geared toward establishing the SoS VO as

e second phase of planned SoS VO capabilities is intended to expand the reach of cybersecurity science information to a much broader community of users. One of the exciting features being developed will allow videos of research reviews to be viewed online in both real-time streaming and archived formats. is capability should permit users to become involved much more easily in reviews without the time and budget constraints of long distance travel. Discussion forums, blogs, content subscriptions, chat, wikis, and user pro les are being created to permit increased interaction among users and to promote simple forms of collaboration.


FIGURE 1. The Science of Security Virtual Organization (SoS VO) enables those interested in cybersecurity science to survey current research; stay current on news in the eld; nd out about events related to cybersecurity science; collaborate with others using chat, video conferencing, and forums; share work by uploading documents and creating wikis; and access educational resources contributed by members. Visit to learn more.

The Next Wave | Vol. 19 No. 4 | 2012 | 23

Advancing the science of cybersecurity with a virtual organization

Phase 3. Strengthen collaboration with social networking.

About the authors
Frankie D. King is the assistant director of the Annapolis Technical Coordination Project O ce at Vanderbilt University’s Institute for So ware Integrated Systems (VU-ISIS), where she is responsible for managing the coordination of collaborative research and development activities on the Cyber-Physical Systems Virtual Organization that are sponsored by federal agencies belonging to the Networking and Information Technology Research and Development (NITRD) Program. Before joining VU-ISIS, King served as the technical coordinator for the High Con dence So ware and Systems Program Component Area at the National Coordination O ce for the NITRD Program for nearly seven years. King has over 28 years of program development and management experience in domestic and international policy a airs where she has served in high-level capacities in the executive and legislative branches of the US government and the private sector. King received an MA from the University of Notre Dame and a BA from Fisk University, where she graduated summa cum laude. Heather Lucas is a program director within the Trusted Systems Research Group at NSA and is the current program lead for NSA’s Science of Security Virtual Organization e ort. Robert Meushaw is the former technical director of NSA’s Information Assurance (IA) Research Laboratory. His current work focuses on developing new strategies and programs for the advancement of a science of cybersecurity. He retired from NSA in 2005 a er 33 years of service, including over a decade of work in IA research. Meushaw’s career at NSA also included signi cant stints in both the Product Development Group and the Security Evaluation Group of the IA Directorate. In addition to his technical responsibilities, he served for six years as technical editor of NSA’s Tech Trend Notes and e Next Wave publications. Meushaw holds degrees in electrical engineering from Princeton University and the Johns Hopkins University.

Ultimately, the capabilities delivered by the SoS VO, as well as the CPS VO, were conceived to promote community collaboration in order to advance science. e features deployed in the rst phases of the SoS VO should help to create a broad community of users and establish a focal point for their interactions. But it is the last group of capabilities o ered by the SoS VO that should enable the type of robust collaboration desired by blending elements of social networking with a rich set of communication and research tools. Some of the features currently being planned in this phase include: » Research toolsets and datasets; » On-demand video conferencing; » Desktop sharing; » Individual user space, dashboard, etc.; » Interface personalization; » Subscription services; » Cybersecurity science-related newsfeeds; » A multimedia library; and » Open research support.

SoS VO rollout
e establishment of the SoS VO is founded on the beliefs that open collaboration can play a key role in advancing cybersecurity science and that the availability of a platform where researchers can share, collaborate, and learn is vital to building community. e structure and features of the SoS VO attempt to leverage popular features provided by social networking technology with rich domain-speci c content to create a focal point for cybersecurity science research. e pilot version of the SoS VO has evolved dramatically in form and content since its inception in 2011, and it will continue to evolve as user feedback is received when it becomes operational and as the cybersecurity science community matures.